For years, the accusations surrounding Manchester City hovered over English football like a cloud that refused to move. Now, the storm has finally broken.
An independent commission has found Manchester City guilty of the serious financial charges brought against them by the Premier League, covering nine seasons between 2009/10 and 2017/18. Of the 115 charges commonly associated with the case, reports state that 114 were upheld, including three of four allegations concerning the club’s failure to cooperate. No punishment has yet been imposed, and City continue to deny wrongdoing.
The language in the findings is devastating. The Premier League said City arranged “sham” contracts with commercial partners as part of a disguised funding scheme designed to inflate revenue and reduce costs. The commission also found that the club filed misstated accounts, concealed the true condition of its finances from auditors and regulators, and significantly breached Premier League and UEFA spending limits.
These are not minor accounting errors or administrative oversights. They amount to a finding that the financial picture presented to football’s authorities was fundamentally misleading. That is why this verdict feels so damning. It does not merely question how Manchester City recorded its income. It strikes at the credibility of an era in which the club became the dominant force in English football.
City, however, are not surrendering. Chief executive Ferran Soriano reportedly described the case as a “Premier League conspiracy theory”. At the same time, the club said it would appeal because the opinion contained “clear material errors of law, principle and fact, and is unsafe”. City have promised to pursue every appropriate regulatory and legal avenue available to them.
Football finance expert and former City adviser Stefan Borson offered a bleak assessment of their chances. He described the Premier League’s announcement as “absolutely scathing”, adding: “Shams, misleading auditors, conspiracy. All difficult to prove. Now proved, it is very difficult to unwind on appeal.”
The possible punishments range from a substantial fine and points deduction to relegation or expulsion from the Premier League. The stripping of titles has also been discussed, although sanctions will be decided at a separate hearing and there is no direct precedent for a case of this scale. Whatever happens, the punishment must be proportionate enough to show that financial rules apply to every club, regardless of its wealth, power or success.
This is also a defining moment for the Premier League. By pursuing one of its most commercially valuable members, it has shown a willingness to confront power within its own walls. But the league will now be judged by the consistency, transparency and speed of what follows. A weak punishment could damage its credibility; an excessive one could invite accusations that the process has become political.
Questions may eventually extend beyond football. Findings involving allegedly misstated accounts could attract the attention of tax or corporate authorities, including HMRC. However, no public evidence currently establishes tax wrongdoing, so any suggestion of HMRC action must remain a possibility rather than a fact. Sponsors, meanwhile, will be examining contractual morality clauses, reputational exposure and whether continued association still represents good value.
And then there are the supporters. Owners come and go. Executives move on. Players eventually leave. The fans remain. They did not negotiate the contracts, prepare the accounts or present evidence to the commission. Yet they must live with the ridicule, suspicion and shame now attached to their club. Whatever punishment follows, it should be remembered that Manchester City’s supporters are not guilty.
They celebrated what they believed was real. They built memories with parents, children and friends. They do not deserve to have those memories turned into evidence against them.
The verdict may stain an ownership and an era. It should not stain the people who simply loved their football club.
Read more: Bayern Munich chief admits surprise at Florian Wirtz’s struggles at Liverpool
Cody Gakpo set to undergo scan on Monday following ankle injury
